All About Movies, Book Reviews, Purely Production

The Embodiment of Peeta

A stellar actor can elevate the worst tripe, while special effects tend to plasticize story, yet the right art direction will add to not only the world but the characters as well. Purely Production is a monthly post where I explore the different elements that affect a finished media, for good or ill. We’ll forget about writing for a moment and delve into all the bedazzling doodads that dress a story.

Purely Production #6: How much did casting Josh Hutcherson play a part in the success of Catching Fire?

Peeta on Tour - Catching Fire

Casting is a huge part of a movie’s production. As visual mediums it makes sense, but there is also the actor’s abilities to consider. Yes, their appearance is important otherwise costuming and set design wouldn’t matter so much, but the audience also wants to feel the character. So the actor has to be able to reflect onto the screen their character’s inner monologue, that intangible furball of thoughts and feelings that define a human being. And that’s not all, it’s important that an actor’s emoting power be just right for the situation and when responding to the other characters.

Now I am not a fangirl of Liam Hemsworth, but I was really impressed how his embodiment of Gale in Catching Fire made me understand that Katniss and Gale were never to be. He knew it, now I know it. We could see it on his face, the fear, the knowledge. Even as he clings to Katniss we see him picking up alternate passions because ultimately he know Katniss better than Katniss knows Katniss. At least concerning her feelings for Peeta. I recently read someone trash Hemsworth for picking this role. Actually I think it was a good choice on his part. Now everyone can see that Liam is just as good a Hemsworth as Chris.

Right off, I have to admit Jennifer Lawrence cast as Katniss Everdeen – a stroke of genius. You might have been on the fence about her in The Hunger Games but there is no doubt after seeing Catching Fire. Of course, this casting was most important and did indeed contribute to the franchise’s success, but what about love interest and co-contender, Peeta Mellark…did his casting matter?

Catching Fire - Josh Hutcherson Calm Down

Okay, let’s be honest. Josh Hutcherson is not the most expressive guy, actor or no. He embodies what you think a stoic man would be like. For Catching Fire, this is exactly what was needed. Katniss is almost obsessively frantic about Peeta’s safety and success. Every decision she makes is what she believes is in the best interest of this goal. She is the embodiment of action and energy. While Peeta is a…bedrock. He is the foundation that supports the pair of them. When Katniss is rash, he is deliberate. When Katniss is desperate, Peeta is matter-of-fact. When Katniss is unfocused, Josh Hutcherson is calm.

What I’m saying is Josh Hutcherson had many moments in Catching Fire where he shined.

Peeta Range - Catching Fire

In discussing this and pondering this fact, I realized that, yes, Josh Hutcherson was a great casting decision. I also realized that the screen adaption had given Hutcherson many opportunities to shine. In developing the relationships in the screenplay the characters had been balanced and developed extensively compared to the book.

While The Hunger Games stayed more true to the point of view of the book, in Catching Fire the same story was treated as a dual point of view. Katniss still took center stage but Peeta became as equally important a point of view. (Even Gale got thrown a few moments in which Liam Hemsworth was also allowed the shine.) This was an extremely good choice story-wise. Even if you don’t care about the outcome of the couple, you do care about Katniss.

By reflecting both characters’ views of the Quarter Quell, we got to see a couple in action; we got to see what happens when one of the pair is suddenly ripped from the other. We got to see what happens when Katniss’ foundation is rocked.

This really goes to show how important writing is to the end product of a movie. Yes, production is important but writing is more important. Set the cast up for success. Give them opportunities to fulfill their role in specific and nuanced moments through the entire movie. Start with a damn good script.

So was Josh Hutcherson’s casting important to Catching Fire’s success? You tell me… What did you think of Catching Fire? Did you read the book? What did you think of the cast? Did any one character stand out to you as better than the rest? Is Josh Hutcherson a good foil for Jennifer Lawrence? Is Liam Hemsworth?

6 thoughts on “The Embodiment of Peeta”

  1. I read the books and was a little concern when Josh Hutcherson was as Peeta I still, he did perfect in the first two movies. But in Mockingjay its a whole new Peeta I’m not sure he can pull it off, let’s just say his acting skills will be put to the test and we have to wait to see the results. By the way I’m super excited about The Hunger Games: Mockingjay pt 1.

    1. That is a really good point, his skills will really be put to the test. I’m going to say I think he’s up to it because I think he did the puppy love crossed with snarky put upon lover really well, the natural next stage is challenging amnesiac! I feel crazy saying it but I’m looking forward to part 1 too!

      BTW what did you think of Fenick and Joann’s casting??

      1. Sam Clafin and Jena Malone were perfect for the the roles of Finnick and Johanna. Its just like what I imaged it when I was reading the book, especially Johanna. The casting for the hunger games is the best.

        Mockingjay is a dark book and I hope they have bring some of that darkness to the movie. (I don’t want to give nothing away)

  2. Hi, thanks for your comment over at ASpaceBlogyssey. You know I am still on the fence about the casting of both of these parts, but I say this as someone who was a big fan of the books. It’s hard to say that the casting should have exactly matched the books, because books and movies are different mediums. I guess my issues with the casting are physical. I recall Katniss as someone with an olive complexion with some native American descent. I also recall her being demure with a slight figure, due to occasional bouts of hunger. When I read how diminutive she was, in my mind this was an even greater challenge for her to overcome, which she did. However, Jennifer Lawrence is like a 5′ 9″ model glamzon. She’s a decent actress, but she isn’t who I would have pictured for the role.

    I imagined Peeta as someone a little taller and bulkier, as he was well fed due to being the baker’s son. So physically, I don’t think the actors match who I pictured from reading the books. But sometimes books can be subjective. There were many people who didn’t seem to realize that Rue was African American.

    1. Yeah as a writer myself I have struggled with what matters – looks or feel. Having pondered this a lot, I struggle less with the lack of realism when it comes to looks because feel for me always trumps the shallow surface stuff. For example, I know in real life Josh is a lot shorter than Jennifer Lawrence but I couldn’t really tell that in the movies. Would I have loved for him to be as tall as Liam Hemsworth, hell to the yeah! But did it matter, not for me. I look at it this way: personally I don’t want to see a whole district of Matthew McConaughey skinny (i.e. starving) clones. That would be too real and turn my stomach.

      I do agree with you that the worst aspect to overcome when adapting a book to the screen is reader anticipation. Readers have had to use their imagination up to that point and what they have imagined is no more wrong than what is cast for the movie. So I feel like all your opinions are equally as valid as my own. Cheers!

Let's talk in the comments...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s